Is a software program engineer an engineer? Combat between tech firms, Alberta engineering regulator lands in Edmonton courtroom

Is a software program engineer an engineer? Combat between tech firms, Alberta engineering regulator lands in Edmonton courtroom

Article content material

A authorized combat pitting Alberta’s skilled engineering regulator towards two tech firms over their use of the phrase “engineer” is underway in an Edmonton courtroom.

On Wednesday, Courtroom of King’s Bench Justice John Little heard arguments within the Affiliation of Skilled Engineers and Geoscientists of Alberta’s (APEGA) proposed injunction towards Jobber and iStock, which APEGA claims ran afoul of the Engineering and Geoscience Professions Act by posting need adverts for software program “engineers.”

Commercial 2

Article content material

Article content material

Jobber and iStock argue the time period software program engineer is broadly understood — each throughout the {industry} and most of the people — as being distinct from the civil, mechanical, chemical and different engineers who fall underneath APEGA’s regulatory umbrella.

Jobber lawyer Amy Cooper accused APEGA of partaking in “regulatory overreach” that might stifle the power of Alberta tech companies to recruit expertise — echoing arguments the Council of Canadian Innovators directed at Premier Danielle Smith final fall.

APEGA is a self-regulating skilled affiliation that licenses people and firms looking for to observe engineering within the province. The Engineering and Geoscience Professions Act, which supplies APEGA is regulatory energy, defines engineering as using math, chemistry, physics or associated topics in work “aimed on the discovery, growth or utilization of matter, supplies or vitality or in every other manner designed for the use and comfort of people.”

To grow to be licensed, an applicant has to satisfy sure moral, skilled and technical necessities, after which they earn the fitting to make use of reserved titles equivalent to skilled engineer (P. Eng).

Article content material

Commercial 3

Article content material

Katrina Haymond, APEGA’s lawyer, stated the affiliation takes a eager curiosity within the “unauthorized use of titles” as a result of it creates confusion about who’s allowed to name themselves an engineer.

She stated software program engineering is a acknowledged engineering self-discipline that can have vital public security impacts if achieved improperly.

Haymond cited self-driving vehicles, nuclear energy, avionics and biomedical fields as areas the place botched software program engineering can have “catastrophic penalties.”

That prompted Little to ask how a photograph database like iStock may trigger an engineering disaster.

“If you would like a photograph of a bald eagle swooping right down to seize a mouse, that’s the place you get it from,” he stated. “How may the general public be impacted by a catastrophic failure?” 

Haymond replied that the harms needn’t be bodily, citing the potential financial hurt that stem from a defective payroll system.

Haymond stated because it stands, anybody who takes a three-week coding boot camp will be employed by Jobber and name themselves a software program engineer.

She added that when iStock was taken over by U.S.-based Getty Pictures, Canadian iStock staff with the title “software program developer” felt American staff with the title “software program engineer” had extra “skilled cachet” and pushed for the adoption of the time period.

Commercial 4

Article content material

“It’s very clear that the aim of utilizing this title is as a result of staff need to convey a better rank of their group, and have a title they haven’t earned by way of their registration with APEGA,” she stated.

iStock and Jobber argue that if legislators have a difficulty with using the time period software program engineer, they need to replace the act — which Cooper stated hasn’t seen a big modification with regard to titles since 1981.

She stated APEGA is looking for to treatment an issue that doesn’t exist. Jobber sells off-the-shelf software program that helps contractors and home-based companies with scheduling, billing and different administrative duties.

“Nobody is coming to them for engineering companies,” she stated. “Nowhere in its identify does it counsel it sells engineering companies.” 

All iStock and Jobber have achieved is use an industry-accepted time period internally and on job websites the place the “breadth and customary utilization” of the time period is nicely understood, she stated.  

“There’s nothing within the work that Jobber is doing that … goes to trigger any hurt that requires regulatory oversight by APEGA,” stated Cooper.  

Little reserved his determination for a later date.

[email protected]

Article content material


Postmedia is dedicated to sustaining a vigorous however civil discussion board for dialogue and encourage all readers to share their views on our articles. Feedback might take as much as an hour for moderation earlier than showing on the location. We ask you to maintain your feedback related and respectful. We’ve enabled e mail notifications—you’ll now obtain an e mail if you happen to obtain a reply to your remark, there may be an replace to a remark thread you observe or if a person you observe feedback. Go to our Group Pointers for extra info and particulars on how one can regulate your e mail settings.

Be a part of the Dialog

Commercial 1